KUALA LUMPUR, Oct 28 — Bandar Kuching MP Dr Kelvin Yii today called for additional and unique powers for a proposed Health Service Commission (SPK) via amendments to the Federal Constitution.
Health Minister Dzulkefly Ahmad announced in the Dewan Rakyat yesterday the government’s plans to establish an SPK before the end of the 15th Parliament, but said the Health Service Commission wouldn’t have the power to create new positions or set emoluments because service commissions are restricted under Article 144 of the Federal Constitution.
“Of course we support a needed constitutional amendment to give the authority and the powers to this health commission because I think fundamentally we want the health commission to have such powers to make decisions on employment, positions, and even the remuneration of health care workers itself.
“That’s the root cause of the problems that the commission wants to address,” Dr Yii told CodeBlue on the sidelines of the Industry Leadership Summit 2026 here today.
“But I also understand the limitations. Maybe we can set up such a health commission first to manage the different things that Dzulkefly mentioned yesterday and then eventually push for a constitutional amendment to give more powers.
“I think it could be a progressive step, but the fundamental question is you still need to give powers to the commission.”
Dzulkefly told parliamentarians yesterday that like other service commissions, an SPK would only have the power to appoint, confirm, and place officers in permanent or pensionable positions, as well as to exercise disciplinary control over officers, under Article 144 of the Federal Constitution.
The authority to create new positions and set emoluments will remain under the Public Service Department (JPA) and the Ministry of Finance (MOF), as per the Financial Procedure Act 1957.
When asked if a constitutional amendment bill to empower a Health Service Commission to create positions and determine remuneration of health care workers would likely get two-thirds support in the Dewan Rakyat, Dr Yii said the government must have clear engagements with various MPs, parties, as well as relevant non-governmental organisations (NGOs) and stakeholders.
“I think yesterday’s announcement was an announcement of intention. So, until and unless, we have seen the details of such a proposal, there is no guarantee that you can pass, even in Parliament, rather than just a constitutional amendment,” said the Sarawakian MP.
“We need to see the details of the bill itself before a decision is made.”
Unlike other sectors in public service with their own service commissions, such as education, judicial and legal service, police, and military, the health service is unique because the Ministry of Health (MOH) is the country’s main health care provider.
Doctors and nurses also have a much bigger opportunity to move to either the private sector or overseas, compared to other professions like teachers or police officers, as seen with rising attrition from the health service and no-shows for permanent positions.
Dzulkefly told Parliament in a written reply that the MOH had more than 13,000 vacancies for doctors as of June 30. A total of 3,510 medical officers resigned between 2024 and 2026, comprising 1,252 permanent and 2,258 contract doctors.
Health workers are currently regulated, along with other civil servants, under the Public Service Commission (SPA).

