Beyond The Building: Examining Systems At Klinik Kesihatan Kuala Lumpur — A Concerned Health Care Staff Member

Klinik Kesihatan Kuala Lumpur must review how specialists, gazettees, trainees, and medical officers are deployed to ensure fair workloads and clinical coverage. Clearer roles for nurses, assistant MOs, and support staff could also improve patient flow.

Klinik Kesihatan Kuala Lumpur, a government health clinic on Jalan Temerloh in Taman Tasik Titiwangsa, began operating on April 3, 2017.

The Kuala Lumpur and Putrajaya Federal Territory Health Department describes it as Malaysia’s largest health clinic, with capacity to accommodate up to 3,500 people a day and a broad range of primary care services.

The department also describes the facility as a clinic within a garden, set on a 4.5 hectare site with environmentally friendly features. Yet a well-presented building cannot, on its own, show how effectively the systems inside it function.

This article calls for a fair, evidence-based examination of staffing arrangements, workload distribution, training provision, role allocation, and operational oversight at Klinik Kesihatan Kuala Lumpur.

The concerns discussed should be assessed against records and the perspectives of those affected, rather than treated as established findings.

The aim is to support patient care, adequate service coverage, appropriate training opportunities, and a sustainable working environment.

A starting point for this examination is how specialist staffing translates into clinical coverage. The following section considers the arrangements for balancing consultations, administrative duties and external commitments, including how supervision and cover are organised.

These questions concern service design and should not, without supporting evidence, be read as findings about any individual’s conduct or performance.

Family Medicine Specialists

At the family medicine specialist (FMS) level, I request a review of how specialist staffing translates into daily clinical coverage. The concerns raised relate to the balance between patient consultations and their other responsibilities, and the extent to which gazettees and trainees help to cover the absence of FMS within the clinic.

Administrative work is recognised as a necessary part of the service; however, its scheduling should be examined to ensure that adequate specialist availability is maintained during periods of high patient demand. Where feasible, consideration could be given to scheduling such work in the afternoon.

Furthermore, FMS commitments outside the clinic should also be considered as some FMSes are often away from the clinic for courses, conferences and meetings which may not be necessary.

While external responsibilities may form a legitimate part of the specialist role, frequent unavailability requires explicit coverage arrangements rather than an assumption that gazettees or trainees can adequately absorb the workload.

I am concerned that such coverage may be expected without an adequate handover or clearly defined arrangements for specialist supervision and advice.

There is also a concern that, when errors occur, responsibility may be assigned solely to the gazettee or trainee providing cover, without sufficient consideration of the delegation, handover and supervision arrangements.

Care should be made to consider whether such responsibilities can be carried out virtually as much as possible to allow for their clinical role within the clinic, for example, seeing patients while attending meetings online.

In addition, clear boundaries are also needed for delegated tasks, particularly where requests involve private matters or work for external institutions rather than the clinic’s clinical and training responsibilities.

This is a clear abuse of power, and the power imbalance between the FMSes and gazettees or trainees make such requests difficult to refuse. This is because the gazettees or trainees may consider complying with such unwarranted requests as part of the requirement to pass their gazettement or training, which is often not the case.

However, those who hold less power may find it difficult to say no as they might feel their position could be jeopardized as they are being evaluated and refusing such requests may look badly on them.

Family Medicine Specialists (Gazettees)

For doctors undergoing gazettement, the coverage arrangements discussed above raise a related question: how are service requirements balanced with preparation for specialist practice?

I am concerned that gazettees are being required to undertake medical officer (MO) duties primarily because they occupy MO posts, even though the ratio of gazettees to MOs is understood to be approximately 10 per cent, reportedly comparable with other clinics.

These figures should be verified against staffing records and comparable clinic arrangements. My concern is that prioritising routine service gap coverage may reduce the specialist experience that gazettement is intended to provide.

The instruction for gazettees to undertake MO duties undermine their authority and defies the process of shaping them to become specialists of their own rights.

Furthermore, the instruction comes as a form of power imbalance as the gazettees will feel compelled to accept these assignments for fear that raising objections or declining them could jeopardise successful completion of gazettement.

Gazettees should be supported in learning the responsibilities of specialist practice and treated with professional respect, particularly because they may subsequently be posted elsewhere as the sole specialist at a facility.

As such, instead of assigning them to fill up the gaps in services when large numbers of MOs take leave or sick leave, they should receive opportunities to address specialist learning and experience. It is never right to punish those who are capable just because they show up and work.

Furthermore, there are concerns that some doctors that have just completed gazettement may not be up to par in terms of their professionalism (as seen by their frequent tardiness to work, as well as their frequent absences, including missing in action from work) and their clinical knowledge.

Even though these issues were raised to the respective supervising FMS, it seems the issues were simply dismissed.

This raises the issue of how the gazettement evaluation process should be carried out. Although the expectation is that not all FMSes are similar in standards, there should be basic professionalism, and they need to be able to practice medicine safely especially in a primary care setting where we are the first line gatekeepers.

The review should examine whether assessment requirements and completion decisions are transparent, evidence-based and consistently applied.

Having said that, concerns arising in such individual cases should be addressed through appropriate processes rather than generalised to the entire cohort.

Family Medicine Trainees

The balance between service provision and learning also matters for family medicine trainees, but their staffing arrangements differ from those of gazettees.

Although their numbers may appear substantial, many are in Jawatan Simpanan Latihan (JSL) arrangements rather than occupying MO posts. The review should clarify how these arrangements are accounted for in staffing plans and whether trainees are being relied upon to cover gaps arising from MO leave or medical leave.

Service allocation should take account of their training stage and learning needs, rather than treating trainee numbers as interchangeable with established service staffing.

For third-year trainees with limited primary care experience, appropriately supervised exposure to the MO patient pool may be more beneficial than an allocation focused predominantly on FMS patients.

There are concerns that some Malaysia-Ireland Training Programme for Family Medicine (MINTFM) trainees who have completed their training and need not attend their weekly classes are misusing the system by intentionally keeping their supervisor aloof while missing from work on a weekly basis.

I request written confirmation of the applicable MINTFM completion requirements and the process for verifying and documenting completion. The review should clarify the requirements for Wednesday attendance, including who is required to attend, the activities and hours covered, and any provisions for approved absence or conflicting clinical duties.

These requirements should be communicated clearly and reflected in staffing and training arrangements so that trainees can meet their obligations without uncertainty about competing service responsibilities.

Medical Officers (MOs)

These training questions are closely connected to the clinic’s established service capacity. Examining MO availability alongside gazettee and trainee allocations would help distinguish planned learning opportunities from arrangements made to cover staffing shortfalls.

At the MO level, staffing availability and the arrangements for managing concurrent absences warrant particular attention.

It has come to attention that up to 30 per cent of MOs may be unavailable in the clinic at a given time; this figure should be verified against staffing and attendance records before conclusions are drawn.

However, the review should examine how planned leave, medical leave and course attendance affect clinical capacity, and whether supervisory arrangements provide sufficient oversight of minimum staffing needs.

Briefly, the MOs who are unavailable are often the same, and this raises the issue of unfairness in workload distribution. This highlights the incapabilities of the supervising FMSes in handling staff as actions were not taken.

Instead, this kind of bad behaviour is not being reprimanded or taken actions against. In contrast, the bad behaviour of these MOs is being compensated by those who do turn up to work and tend to share a heavier patient workload.

The objective should be a fair and workable coverage system that respects legitimate leave while avoiding routine reliance on gazettees, trainees, and other available MOs to absorb staffing shortfalls.

Assistant Medical Officers (AMOs) And Nurses

Staffing coverage is only one part of the operational picture. The next question is how duties and patient flow are organised across the wider clinical team, within each profession’s permitted scope of practice.

The deployment of assistant medical officers (AMOs) and nurses should also be examined. There is a dire need to clarify how staff at stations with fluctuating patient demand can contribute elsewhere when their assigned station is quiet.

A review of duties and workflow could establish whether their available capacity is being matched appropriately to the clinic’s needs. I request clarification into the role of AMOs especially in patient consultation.

As far as I understand, AMOs are trained for patient consultation especially for simple, stable cases. This is the reason why AMOs are stationed in Klinik Komuniti (KKOM) (previously known as Klinik 1 Malaysia) and in some Klinik Desa.

Hence, AMOs can take up a much prominent role in patient consultation and ease up on the clinical workload among the MOs. The AMOs can see simple stable cases, leaving more time for the MOs to handle the more difficult and complex cases.

Thus, the review should establish what duties are permitted and whether appropriate opportunities exist for AMOs to support patient consultations and patient flow.

Health Care Assistants (PPKs)

Alongside clinical deployment, the clinic’s workflow depends on clearly allocated operational support. The final staffing section considers how support duties fit into patient flow and appointment administration.

As such, the role of PPKs likewise requires clearer definition within the overall clinic workflow. The review should clarify their expected duties, how their time is allocated and whether the current arrangements provide the operational support needed by clinical staff.

Now, some PPKs are working hard in supporting the doctors while some are not. Those who are not, are hidden in plain sight, at work but not at work as they are often on their phones.

Perhaps, in addition to locating forms and undertaking runner duties, consideration could be given to more support for appointment administration or additional appointment counters.

Any revised allocation should be consistent with their designated responsibilities and the clinic’s operational requirements.

Conclusion

Taken together, these concerns point to the need for a clinic-wide review. I respectfully request that management examine specialist clinical coverage and the balance between clinic duties and external commitments, MO staffing and absence arrangements, gazettement and trainee learning opportunities, and the deployment of nursing, AMOs, and PPKs.

The review should consider the available records and the perspectives of the relevant staff groups so that any findings and proposed changes are balanced and grounded in the clinic’s actual operating needs.

My intention is to merely seek a coordinated response to concerns that affect the clinic.

The author is a health care worker in the Klang Valley.

  • This is the personal opinion of the writer or publication and does not necessarily represent the views of CodeBlue.

You may also like