MOH Must Become An Employer That Doctors Actually Want To Work For — Dr R 

The problem with MOH isn’t simply about salaries, long working hours, or staff shortages. It’s about an organisational culture that often treats highly trained professionals as manpower to fulfil service requirements rather than skilled individuals.

There is something fundamentally wrong with the way the Ministry of Health (MOH) manages its professional workforce.

For an organisation employing thousands of highly educated professionals, including doctors, pharmacists, dentists, and other health care professionals, one would expect a modern, progressive, and professional working environment. Unfortunately, the experiences of many health care professionals suggest otherwise.

The problem is not simply about salaries, long working hours, or staff shortages. It is about an organisational culture that often treats highly trained professionals as manpower to fulfil service requirements rather than skilled individuals deserving of dignity, appropriate working conditions, professional development, and career autonomy.

Perhaps it is time we asked ourselves: is MOH actually a good employer for highly educated professionals?

Basic Workplace Facilities Are Lacking

Consider something as basic as parking. Specialists, including established consultants, are not necessarily provided with designated parking spaces.

They often have to compete with patients and visitors, searching for an available parking spot before starting their clinical duties. If even specialists are not given this basic consideration, what more can be said about medical officers?

The situation inside hospitals is equally disappointing. Many medical officers and even specialists are not provided with proper individual workspaces, desks, or lockers.

These are not extravagant demands. They are basic workplace facilities that most professional organisations would consider standard.

Imagine spending years obtaining a medical degree, postgraduate qualifications, and specialist credentials, only to arrive at work without a proper desk to call your own or a locker to keep your belongings. How difficult is it for an organisation as large as MOH to provide these basic facilities?

Doctors Are Expected To Fund Their Own Professional Development

Medicine is a constantly evolving profession. Guidelines change, new treatments emerge, technologies advance, and clinical knowledge becomes outdated.

Continuous professional development is not a luxury for doctors. It is a professional necessity. Yet, opportunities for medical officers and specialists to attend professional conferences, seminars, workshops, and clinical courses are often limited by the availability of departmental or institutional funding.

In many instances, doctors have to pay for these opportunities themselves, particularly medical officers. This includes registration fees, transportation, accommodation, and other associated expenses.

The irony is that doctors are expected to maintain their clinical competency, acquire new skills, and keep up with international medical standards, yet the organisation does not consistently provide sufficient financial support to facilitate this.

How can an organisation expect its professionals to remain competitive internationally when it does not adequately invest in their professional development? Investing in doctors’ knowledge and skills is ultimately an investment in patient care.

The Condition Of On-Call Accommodation Is Unacceptable

Another issue that deserves attention is the condition of on-call accommodation. Medical officers and many specialists are expected to remain within the hospital during on-call duties.

This is understandable given the nature of hospital medicine and the need for immediate clinical availability. However, the accommodation provided in some hospitals, particularly older institutions, can be extremely disappointing.

Rooms may be poorly maintained, uncomfortable, and far from what one would consider an appropriate resting environment for professionals who are expected to make critical clinical decisions throughout the night.

Compare this with the corporate sector. When employees are required to work away from their usual office or home, accommodation is often provided in decent hotels.

Even officers from other government ministries may receive better accommodation arrangements and travel-related benefits when undertaking official duties away from their usual workplace.

Why should doctors, who are responsible for managing critically ill patients and making life-and-death decisions, be expected to tolerate sub-standard resting facilities?

A doctor who is expected to make sound clinical decisions at 3.00am deserves an adequate environment to rest. This is not about demanding luxury. It is about basic human dignity and occupational welfare.

The Corporate Sector Offers Considerably Better Employment Packages

Let’s be honest. When it comes to employment benefits, the corporate sector often offers considerably more attractive packages.

Better salaries, annual bonuses, private medical insurance, dental coverage, optical benefits, allowances, and other employee perks are common features in many established corporations. The overall financial compensation can be substantially better.

Of course, benefits differ between companies, industries, and seniority levels. Not every corporate employee enjoys these privileges. Nevertheless, the difference in employment packages can be striking.

Doctors in MOH, particularly medical officers and specialists, often face considerable professional responsibilities, long working hours, on-call duties, and significant personal sacrifices. Yet, the financial and non-financial rewards do not always reflect the demands placed upon them.

We should stop assuming that doctors will remain in public service simply because medicine is a noble profession. Passion for medicine does not mean that doctors should be expected to accept inferior employment conditions indefinitely.

The Opportunity Cost Of Choosing Medicine

Choosing medicine comes with significant sacrifices. Beyond the five to six years of undergraduate education, doctors often spend another several years pursuing postgraduate qualifications and specialist training.

This represents a substantial investment of time, money, and personal commitment. However, when we examine the employment landscape across other professional sectors, an uncomfortable reality emerges.

Professionals in fields such as engineering, finance, accounting, information technology, and the corporate sector often have access to more competitive remuneration packages, annual performance bonuses, private medical insurance, dental and optical benefits, better workplace facilities, and more flexible career opportunities. Of course, these benefits vary between industries and employers. Not everyone in the private sector enjoys such privileges.

The point, however, is that medicine is no longer automatically an attractive career when assessed from the perspective of financial returns, employment benefits, and quality of life.

Doctors undertake years of demanding education, carry substantial professional responsibilities, and frequently sacrifice their personal time through prolonged working hours and on-call commitments.

Yet, the employment packages offered to many doctors, particularly medical officers and specialists, do not always reflect these demands.

This raises an important question. Why should a profession requiring such extensive training and carrying such significant responsibilities offer comparatively limited employment benefits?

We should not expect doctors to remain in public service purely because medicine is a vocation. Professional dedication and fair employment conditions should coexist.

Ultimately, choosing medicine should not mean accepting a lifetime of compromised financial opportunities, professional development, and quality of life.

A Rigid Employment Structure That Limits Professional Autonomy

Beyond facilities and remuneration, there is also the issue of career progression. The pathway towards becoming a recognised specialist in Malaysia remains heavily influenced by government training structures, institutional requirements, and regulatory recognition.

Although alternative training pathways exist, opportunities outside the public sector remain limited in capacity and accessibility. This creates an uncomfortable situation where doctors may feel that their professional future is closely tied to remaining within a particular employment ecosystem.

A modern health care system should encourage multiple accredited pathways towards specialist development. The Ministry of Higher Education (MOHE), universities, private hospitals, and other accredited institutions should have greater opportunities to participate in specialist training.

The MOH and MOHE should not have to carry the entire responsibility for producing Malaysia’s specialist workforce. A more competitive and open training ecosystem would give doctors greater professional choices while encouraging institutions to improve the quality of their training and employment environments.

A Culture That Discourages Those Who Speak Up

It would be unfair to suggest that everyone in MOH’s leadership is indifferent to the welfare of doctors. There are heads of department (HODs) who genuinely care about their staff, understand the challenges on the ground, and make sincere efforts to improve working conditions.

Some take the initiative to raise concerns with hospital directors and higher authorities, hoping to secure better facilities, more resources, and improved working arrangements for their departments.

Unfortunately, these efforts do not always translate into meaningful changes. In some instances, concerns raised by departmental leaders are simply dismissed or ignored.

There are also concerns about senior colleagues being moved from their positions under the pretext of routine “rotation”, sometimes leaving the impression that speaking up or challenging existing decisions comes with professional consequences.

Whether intentional or not, such experiences can create a culture where people become increasingly reluctant to voice legitimate concerns.

The result is an unfortunate environment in which some leaders may prioritise maintaining good relationships with hospital directors and higher authorities over advocating for the needs of their own departments.

After all, career progression, promotions, and senior administrative appointments are often influenced by the very hierarchy within which these individuals operate. When career advancement becomes closely associated with pleasing those in positions of authority, organisational improvement can take a back seat.

This is particularly unfortunate because HODs should be empowered to advocate for their departments, not placed in a position where they have to choose between speaking up for their staff and protecting their own career prospects.

A healthy organisation should welcome constructive criticism, encourage transparency and reward leaders who identify problems and propose solutions. We cannot expect meaningful organisational reform when the very people who recognise the problems are discouraged from speaking about them.

Who Evaluates The People In Positions Of Power?

In most organisations, employees are subjected to performance assessments by their superiors. Their productivity, conduct, leadership, and overall performance are evaluated as part of their career progression.

But what about the people at the top? Hospital directors and HODs make decisions that directly affect the working conditions, welfare, professional development, and morale of hundreds of health care professionals.

Yet, there is often limited opportunity for the people working under them to formally evaluate their leadership and management. Perhaps it is time for MOH to introduce a structured, 360-degree leadership evaluation system.

Medical officers, specialists, nurses, pharmacists and other health care professionals should be given the opportunity to anonymously evaluate their respective HODs and hospital directors.

The assessment could cover several areas, including:

  • Leadership and management capabilities.
  • Fairness and transparency in decision-making.
  • Staff welfare and working conditions.
  • Ability to listen to feedback and address legitimate concerns.
  • Professionalism, communication, and interpersonal conduct.
  • Efforts to improve departmental services and staff development.

Most importantly, the evaluation must be genuinely anonymous and independently administered. Individual responses should never be accessible to the leaders being evaluated, and there must be safeguards against retaliation or attempts to identify staff who have provided negative feedback.

The results should be incorporated into leadership performance reviews, with appropriate mechanisms for improvement, accountability and, where necessary, reconsideration of leadership appointments.

Of course, leadership should not be judged purely by popularity. Running a hospital is complicated, and sometimes difficult decisions are unavoidable.

A good director or HOD may have to make unpopular decisions for the benefit of patients and the institution.

However, there is a difference between making difficult decisions and being a poor leader. A leader should be evaluated not only by how well they satisfy their superiors, but also by how effectively they manage, support, and develop the people under their leadership.

Leadership accountability should not operate in only one direction. If subordinates are expected to be accountable to their superiors, surely those in positions of authority should also be accountable to the people they lead.

Doctors Deserve To Be Treated As Professionals, Not Merely Manpower

Ultimately, this is about organisational culture. Doctors are not simply manpower to fill rosters, cover on-call shifts, and meet service requirements.

They are highly trained professionals who have invested years of their lives in acquiring knowledge and clinical expertise. They deserve appropriate facilities, reasonable accommodation, opportunities for professional development, competitive remuneration, and a working environment that respects their professional standing.

An organisation cannot continuously demand sacrifice, loyalty, and commitment without offering something meaningful in return. There is a difference between working in a challenging profession and being subjected to unnecessarily poor employment conditions.

It is time for MOH to rethink how it treats its workforce. The ministry frequently highlights doctor shortages, workforce retention, and the need to strengthen the public health care system.

But perhaps we should also ask a more fundamental question: why should an organisation that depends so heavily on highly educated professionals continue to offer employment conditions that make so many of them question their future in public service?

Doctors do not necessarily leave because they dislike medicine or no longer want to serve the public.

Some leave because they can find better employment conditions elsewhere. Some leave because they want professional autonomy.

Others simply want to work in an environment where their years of education, expertise and personal sacrifices are recognised and valued. We should stop using the noble nature of medicine as an excuse for inadequate employment conditions.

Doctors can be passionate about serving patients while simultaneously expecting competitive salaries, decent accommodation, professional development funding, and basic workplace facilities. These expectations are not unreasonable.

The public health care system depends on its people. Buildings, medical equipment, technology, and infrastructure are important, but none of these can replace a competent, motivated, and adequately supported workforce.

MOH needs to understand that retaining doctors requires more than asking them to serve with dedication. It requires becoming an employer that doctors actually want to work for.

The author is a physician in public service. CodeBlue is providing the author anonymity because civil servants are prohibited from writing to the press.

  • This is the personal opinion of the writer or publication and does not necessarily represent the views of CodeBlue.

You may also like