KUALA LUMPUR, Oct 2 — Significant interventions by the Sabah state government in addressing medical officers’ refusal to serve in Sabah are conditional upon decentralisation and remit of the state’s constitutional 40 per cent revenue entitlement.
Medical associations and doctors have urged the Sabah and Sarawak state governments to “play their part” in attracting doctors to serve in Borneo, such as by improving staff accommodation and providing state-funded salary increments, allowances, or retention bonuses.
CodeBlue asked Sabah Deputy Chief Minister II Masidi Manjun today, who is also the state finance minister, whether the state government would be willing to spend its own budget on these measures.
“Isn’t that a financial and constitutional responsibility of the federal government?” he replied. “It’s a ‘package’ responsibility; you cannot choose and pick which one you want to pay.”
The national health service by the Ministry of Health (MOH) is under federal jurisdiction. Only certain health-related matters – public health and sanitation – fall under the Concurrent List of the Federal Constitution, with shared responsibilities between the federal and state governments.
The recruitment, retention, career development, remuneration, and welfare of doctors and other health care workers all fall under Putrajaya’s purview. State governments, including Sabah and Sarawak, have little to no say in the health service, although Sarawak has been particularly vocal in demanding for health autonomy.
High no-shows have been unofficially reported in Sabah and Sarawak in the current permanent appointment intake of more than 4,200 medical officers nationwide, including 100 per cent no-shows in Sabah hospitals like Keningau, Beluran, and Sipitang that saw zero medical officers reporting for duty last September 28. Beluran Hospital is reportedly being run by just six doctors.
Doctor no-shows for permanent positions in other public health care facilities in Sabah ranged from 67 per cent in Lahad Datu Hospital to 76 per cent in the Kudat regional health office. The Malaysian Medical Association (MMA) Sabah reported a 66 per cent no-show rate for hospital postings in Sabah involving medical officers from outside the state.
When asked what the state government was planning to do or if it was simply waiting for the MOH to take action, Masidi told CodeBlue that a briefing on the issue of doctor no-shows would be held in the next state Cabinet meeting. “We’ll take it from there.”
“But suffice to say that the Sabah government would definitely be able to do more if the federal government remits us Sabah’s constitutional entitlement of the 40 per cent share of revenue,” added Masidi, who is also Karanaan state assemblyman and GRS deputy chairman.
“There is also a need for decentralisation of important development decisions, though it would only be effective if the state has a greater share of the federal revenue collected in Sabah.
“Sabah is a huge state. My own district Ranau is bigger than Melaka and Kinabatangan is bigger than Pahang.”
On October 29, the Court of Appeal is set to hear the federal government’s appeal against a landmark High Court ruling last year that Sabah is entitled to 40 per cent of net federal revenue collected from the state, a right under Article 112C of the Federal Constitution.
The High Court ordered the federal and Sabah governments to conduct a review of the entitlement for each financial year from 1974 to 2021 and to reach an agreement on the matter. Last April, the Court of Appeal granted a stay of execution of the High Court’s order, pending disposal of the appeal.

