KUALA LUMPUR, Nov 18 — A former Poisons Board member has cast doubt on the effectiveness of the Control of Smoking Products for Public Health Act 2024 (Act 852) in controlling vapes.
Dr Ashok Philip – a former Malaysian Medical Association (MMA) president who was part of the Poisons Board that opposed exempting liquid nicotine from the Poisons List in 2023 – opined that the existence of Act 852 wasn’t a good justification for the Poisons Board to recently endorse a proposal to once again remove the substance from the list of scheduled poisons under the Poisons Act 1952 (Act 366).
“The long-term aim is to stop having these e-cigarettes, vapes, and electronic delivery systems.
“If we make it easier now, or make it less regulated, it makes it more difficult to remove vape from the landscape in the long term because it becomes more and more lucrative for dealers and the government collecting tax. It becomes more difficult to legislate against it,” Dr Ashok told Astro Awani’s Consider This host Melisa Idris last night.
Although Act 852, which came into force in October 2024, prohibits the sale of conventional and electronic cigarettes to minors, Dr Ashok said the tobacco and vape control law was still new.
“For enforcement under this Act, we don’t have an historical record of it. We don’t know how it’s going to be,” he said.
The physician expressed concerns about vape packaging and flavours designed to appeal to young people and those who don’t traditionally smoke, besides the scale of enforcement needed to check the contents of vape liquids besides nicotine, where the components come from, and ensuring that people who are not supposed to buy them don’t end up doing so.
“It’s a huge logistical problem,” said Dr Ashok. “If we keep it [liquid nicotine] in the Poisons List, it’s much more difficult for people to get it. But under the new Act, it’s much more difficult to regulate.”
CodeBlue recently found at least one convenience store in Kuala Lumpur that showed promotional posters of heated tobacco and vape products next to white panels concealing these products. It’s unclear if the images of brand names and products are in violation of a retail display ban under Act 852.
Following the Poisons Board’s approval, Health Minister Dzulkefly Ahmad has yet to gazette an order exempting liquid and gel nicotine used in e-cigarettes and vape from the Poisons List.
He confirmed in a written parliamentary reply last November 5 that after the High Court nullified the 2023 exemption of liquid nicotine from the Poisons List last May, liquid nicotine was once again a scheduled poison subject to Act 366.
Dr Ashok revealed that he resigned from the Poisons Board, “as a matter of principle”, after then-Health Minister Dr Zaliha Mustafa vetoed the Board’s unanimous opposition to removing liquid nicotine from the Poisons List and proceeded with gazetting the exemption order on March 31, 2023. But MMA, which he represented, did not leave the Poisons Board.
When Melisa asked whether MMA’s current representative or other Poisons Board members who objected to a renewed nicotine exemption should resign in protest, Dr Ashok disagreed, citing the wide responsibilities of the statutory body in scheduling drugs.
“Those are important to doctors and dentists. We should remain there. Pharmacists should remain on the Board as well. It’s not a single-issue Board. If we step out, then of course we lose our say,” he said. “Having said that, we object to this. The president of MMA has made his views clearly known.”
The former Poisons Board member also said the reported secret ballot held by the Poisons Board recently in voting on whether to exempt liquid nicotine from the Poisons List, before deciding to approve the proposed exemption, indicated that the proposal was controversial.
“It suggests the Ministry of Health (MOH) or government felt that an open vote would have gone against them,” said Dr Ashok.
“It also suggests that they understand that liquid nicotine is a controversial matter. As such, they should have held more consideration on the matter before going forward. They should have held more consultation with interested parties,” he added, citing specialty societies like addiction, paediatric, and chest medicine.
Dr Ashok said when he was in the Poisons Board, no secret ballots were held and matters were discussed openly, usually with a show of hands if necessary. Decisions were typically made in consensus.
He added that even though he was required to sign a document to avoid disclosing the discussions in Poisons Board meetings to the public, there was a general exemption to disclosure. “If I’m representing MMA, I’m expected to brief my association on what has happened.”
Galen Centre: Nicotine Vape ‘Technically’ Illegal Today

Galen Centre for Health and Social Policy chief executive Azrul Mohd Khalib, who also spoke on Consider This last night, explained that nicotine vapes are “technically” illegal today due to the High Court’s judgment six months ago, pending the gazettement of a new nicotine exemption order by the health minister.
“Until he issues that order, nicotine vapes are illegal to be sold in retail, outside of authorised avenues,” Azrul told Melisa.
As a Group C poison, liquid nicotine can only be sold and supplied by licensed pharmacists and registered medical practitioners.
“The High Court practically handed a ban to the government on a plate, oven-ready, with its judgment. The government even dropped its appeal. The government could have given the industry a six-month period to prepare for the ban,” said Azrul.
He told the Madani government to be clear about its intentions on whether or not it wanted to ban nicotine vapes, describing the current situation as a “lavender haze” moment. “Does the government want to ban these products or not?”
Malaysia, he noted, was one of the few “outlier” countries in the region that still had yet to prohibit vape.
“The government seems very adamant to want to keep this industry alive. Malaysia is a major manufacturer and exporter of e-cigarette and vape products. We’re unable to shake off our addiction to these products.”
Citing a 2023 affidavit by Treasury secretary-general Johan Mahmood Merican, Azrul also noted that the court’s cancellation of the 2023 nicotine exemption order invalidated the government’s collection of excise duties on nicotine e-liquids that amounted to more than RM354 million.
“All of that money technically has to be refunded to the industry or those who paid that tax,” said Azrul.
“No tax can be collected on an illegal product. So for the government to continue collecting tax, it has to issue the [exemption] order once again as it did back in 2023.”
Dr Ashok said a liquid nicotine delivery system can aid smoking cessation, but only under medical supervision with a medical prescription.
“People who have never smoked should not get the impression that vape is harmless,” he said.

