Antibody, Antigen Rapid Tests Mooted At Private Clinics For 400,000 Workers

MMA supports antibody rapid tests for those returning to work, while FPMPAM highlights antigen rapid tests that require biosafety cabinets and full protective gear at clinics.

KUALA LUMPUR, April 17 — Two doctors’ groups have suggested using either antibody or antigen rapid tests to screen some 400,000 workers approved during the third phase of the Movement Control Order (MCO).

The Malaysian Medical Association (MMA) said it supported the government’s announcement in using the rapid antibody test kit for those who are returning to work, while the Federation of Private Medical Practitioners’ Associations, Malaysia (FPMPAM) highlighted antigen rapid tests that can detect early Covid-19 infection.

Both tests have minutes-long turnaround times and can be done in clinics instead of sending samples to laboratories, compared to the gold-standard PCR tests that take 24 to 48 hours to yield results at laboratories.

MMA urged the Ministry of Health (MOH) to announce a list of reliable tests for use at private general practitioner (GP) clinics to test these workers, since no antibody rapid test kit has been approved for diagnosis of Covid-19 so far.

“This is a point-of-care testing which is done at the clinic itself unlike the antigen test that is done by taking the nasopharynx and oropharynx swab, which needs full personal protective equipment (PPE) and needs training with MOH,” MMA president Dr N. Ganabaskaran told CodeBlue.

“To conduct the finger-prick procedure may take less than three minutes and waiting time for the results is 10 to 15 minutes.”

When pointed out that antibody tests are not recommended for coronavirus diagnosis, as antibodies take days to weeks to develop after a viral infection, Dr Ganabaskaran said these serology tests are meant for screening people returning to work who are not Covid-19 patients-under-investigation (PUI).

Serology tests identify antibodies to the virus that causes Covid-19, whereas antigens are viral proteins expressed only when the virus is actively replicating, so tests based on antigen detection can identify acute or early infection.

“We believe MOH will issue clear guidelines and also interpretation criteria before it’s rolled out,” Dr Ganabaskaran said.

Malaysian Medical Association (MMA) president Dr N. Ganabaskaran. Picture by MMA.

He pointed out that a South Korean antigen rapid test kit that will be procured soon by MOH cannot be used in private GP clinics at the moment as these facilities lack full PPE and biosafety cabinets.

“The GPs are already used to conduct other point-of-care testing like dengue serology which is done using similar methods. The only difference is the GPs need to pre-qualify them as non-PUI and wear appropriate PPEs like face mask, face shield, disposable gloves and a plastic apron,” he said.

The MMA president also said clinics would question patients before testing to get their travel history, symptoms, or possible links with Covid-19 patients, adding that the 3,000 GP clinics identified to screen the 400,000 workers had sufficient testing capacity.

“We believe majority of these workers are in urban and semi-urban area, of which the 80 per cent of clinics are well distributed.”

Tests Only Mandatory For Newly Approved Workers

Economic Affairs Minister Mohamed Azmin Ali speaks at the High-Level Dialogue on Financing for Development on the sidelines of the 74th Session of the United Nations General Assembly in New York, the US, on September 26 2019. Picture from

International Trade and Industry Minister Mohamed Azmin Ali announced yesterday that all workers of companies allowed to operate during the third phase of the MCO are required to undergo Covid-19 screening at any of the Social Security Organisation’s (Socso) over 3,000 panel clinics nationwide. He said Socso will bear the cost of screenings.

An International Trade and Industry Ministry official told CodeBlue that the coronavirus tests were only mandatory for newly approved workers during MCO 3, not those who were already allowed to operate during the earlier phases of the nationwide partial lockdown.

The number of workers from the additional sectors allowed to reopen during the third phase of the MCO are estimated at 400,000, he said. These sectors are the automotive industry; machinery and equipment industry; aerospace industry; construction projects; science, professional and technical services; social health services; hardware shops and electrical and electronic shops; and full-service laundry services.

“Still, not all companies will open operations. Some may just wait till MCO over,” he said.

Testing In Private Clinics Includes Various Costs

Federation of Private Medical Practitioners’ Association, Malaysia (FPMPAM) president Dr Steven Chow. Picture from

FPMPAM urged the government to expand Covid-19 testing for the 400,000 workers to all 7,000 over private family doctors, including those on the Fomema panel. Fomema is a concession company appointed by the government to provide medical examinations for foreign workers in Malaysia.

“To be practical and meaningful, these 400,000 workers will need to be checked and screened as soon as possible. If they are already in the country this will have to be done within a week or so.

“It would work out to more than 10 patients per day for each clinic. This is a massive undertaking,” FPMPAM president Dr Steven Chow told CodeBlue.

Instead of antibody rapid tests, FPMPAM highlighted the currently approved antigen rapid test kits with a turnaround time of 30 minutes.

“The question is whether there is enough stock of these approved tests in the country to cater for 400,000 tests in the weeks to come. Can this be delivered to all the participating clinics nationwide?” Dr Chow questioned.

He highlighted the requirements for a biosafety cabinet and training with Cawangan Kawalan Amalan Perubatan Swasta (CKAPS) in Putrajaya. Dr Chow said.

“The logistics and the fulfillment of the present requirements for Covid-19 testing in private health care facilities will be the bottle-neck and a Catch-22 for its implementation,” he said.

According to FPMPAM, tests currently cost RM50 each, with a minimum doctor’s fee at RM30 per patient, including clinical consultation and examination. This excludes the cost of a biosafety cabinet, PPE and supplies, extra staff, time spent on prerequisite training, and disinfection if Covid-19 cases turn up.

“Will the cost of all this be borne by Socso?” Dr Chow questioned.

“Presently the cost per test per patient is about RM300 when done by mobile teams visiting the place of work. Imagine you have a factory employing 1,000 workers, this is already a disincentive for businesses to restart operations.”

He also asked what would happen if private clinics found positive Covid-19 cases.

“What treatment is the GP allowed to give? Will all the positive cases need to be referred to the government hospitals? As with existing SOP, in the event of any positive case, the doctor and all clinic staff will need to get themselves screened, clinic to be closed and quarantined for 14 days even if negative.

“The operational income will be disrupted for the next 14 days, but operational expenditure will need to be met,” he said.

FPMPAM said the best approach was routine medical screening for all workers and certification by their own company doctors and for the company doctor to do the needful if cases that need further investigation are suspected.

“A question that is often asked is, will all government employees be required to be tested before they resume work following the MCO?”

The Ministry of Human Resources and Socso have yet to reply CodeBlue’s questions about the matter at the time of writing.

You may also like