Same Duty, Different Screen: Digital Care, Evidence, And The Doctor’s Accountability — JJ Chan & Dr Arasu R.

Know what a remote assessment can and cannot establish. Say so to the patient, in terms they understand. Arrange a timely in-person assessment where the limits matter, and ensure appropriate follow-up. And write all of it down.

Part I: The Legal Perspective (JJ Chan)

When a consultation moves from a room to a screen, a natural question follows. Does the law move with it?

For the most part, the law was already there. But it arrived by an unusual route, and the areas it left unsettled are worth knowing.

Malaysia has had a Telemedicine Act since 1997. It was passed and gazetted, but it has not been brought into force. Digital care is instead governed through general legislation, professional regulation and operational guidance.

The framework is layered. The Medical Act 1971 and the Malaysian Medical Council’s guidance govern the practitioner; the Private Healthcare Facilities and Services Act 1998 and the Personal Data Protection Act 2010, as amended, apply where their scope is engaged.

In 2025, the Ministry of Health added a Guideline on Online Healthcare Services, much of it addressed to the platforms themselves: local incorporation and presence, a registered medical practitioner in senior management or on the board, credential checks and proper records. Behind all of it sits the ordinary law of negligence.

So the position is not a vacuum, though there is still no dedicated statute in force for online health care as a system.

Begin with what does not change. The legal standard is not lowered because care is delivered remotely.

Since the Federal Court’s decision in Zulhasnimar in 2017, diagnosis and treatment are judged by the Bolam test as qualified by Bolitho, that is, against a practice accepted as proper by a responsible body of peers that withstands logical scrutiny.

Advice on proposed treatment is judged by a patient-centred standard that extends to material risks and reasonable alternatives, and materiality is for the court, not the profession.

Neither test asks where the doctor was sitting. The Council’s own telemedicine guidance says as much: technology does not alter the ethical, professional or legal requirements of care.

What reasonable care requires, however, is shaped by what the medium can safely establish, including, where it cannot support a safe decision, declining to make one remotely at all.

The medium does not displace the practitioner’s own professional accountability, though it does enlarge the cast. Registration and professional discipline attach to the practitioner personally; commercial arrangements around a consultation may allocate revenue and risk between the parties, but they do not remove the practitioner’s own duty of care or professional accountability.

That does not make the platform legally invisible. The Ministry’s Guideline places requirements on platform providers directly, while directing that, where the professionals are not directly employed by the platform, its terms should disclose that they are independent third parties and that no doctor-patient relationship exists between the platform and the patient.

Those two things sit rather uneasily together, and the space between them is where the unsettled question lies, namely, what duties, if any, the platform itself owes the patient in civil law when it screens and checks the practitioners’ credentials, structures the service and holds the records. Terms of that kind do not by themselves answer the question; the platform’s actual role, the facts and the ordinary law will.

What changes most is the evidence. A remote consultation limits what can be physically examined, but it can leave a detailed digital trail: identity checks, written consent, platform messages, clinical notes and, where captured, recordings.

If a claim or a complaint follows, an important question will be whether that trail shows the limits of the medium were recognised, explained and safely managed.

The Ministry’s Guideline describes its standards for health care professionals as recommended, while also stating that health care professionals shall comply with them. For registered medical practitioners, the Council states that its guidelines must be observed, and that non-compliance may result in disciplinary action under section 29 of the Medical Act.

That is the view from the law. What digitalisation actually does to a doctor’s day is the other half of the story.

Part II: The View From The Profession (Dr Arasu R.)

Why the profession hesitates

It is sometimes assumed that doctors who are cautious about digitalisation are simply resistant to change. That is not what we see. Digital tools are already part of everyday health care, and the direction of travel is not in doubt.

The concern is not the screen itself. It is knowing when the screen is enough, and when it is not.

Much of general practice is pattern recognition across a whole person. The patient who says they are fine but does not look it. The abdomen that must be pressed. The child who is unwell in a way a parent cannot describe and a camera cannot show.

A remote consultation can be entirely appropriate: for a review, a result, a stable condition, a question that does not need hands. It becomes unsafe when it is asked to carry a decision it was never built to carry.

The Council’s guidance recognises that boundary: where the medium does not permit adequate assessment, a timely in-person assessment should be arranged.

Speed is not the same as care

The pressures on that boundary are real. Some commercial models of digital care are designed around convenience and volume: faster consultations, rapid assessments, round-the-clock availability. Those are legitimate things for patients to want.

But convenience and cost savings can never justify cutting corners in patient care. The doctor signs the prescription and answers professionally for the clinical decision, whatever arrangements surround it.

The concern is not that health care has a commercial element. It always has. The concern is when the consultation itself becomes transactional, measured mainly by speed, volume or conversion. A patient is not simply a transaction to be completed. Digital care must remain patient-centred, with enough time for proper clinical judgment, appropriate follow-up and continuity of care.

That is where the profession’s unease properly sits. Not with technology, but with the possibility that clinical judgment is quietly shaped by considerations that are not clinical at all. It is welcome, then, that the Ministry’s Guideline now asks something of the platforms themselves.

And the Council’s own position is more demanding than is sometimes assumed. As a general rule, a virtual consultation should follow a doctor-patient relationship already established in person, as part of follow-up care.

First-contact virtual care is not prohibited. The Council recognises it may be permissible, particularly in primary care, but neither is it the default. Where it is used, the reason must be recorded and the decision defensible afterwards. Since September 2025, the Council has also made one limit explicit: a medical sick certificate may not be issued solely following a virtual consultation.

What good practice looks like now

Within the current framework, the profession is not without an answer, and it is close to what JJ describes from the legal side.

Know what a remote assessment can and cannot establish. Say so to the patient, in terms they understand. Arrange a timely in-person assessment where the limits matter, and ensure appropriate follow-up. And write all of it down. Not defensively, but because on a screen the record may become the critical contemporaneous evidence that a clinical judgment was, in fact, careful.

Every diagnosis, every prescription and every medical decision carries accountability. That has not changed. What has changed is the medium through which the decision is made, and the evidence by which the care taken in making it may later be judged.

The next layer

None of this is an argument against digital medicine. Used well, it can reach patients who would otherwise struggle to be seen, and it can make care more continuous rather than less.

But adoption should not have to be an act of faith.

Malaysia has now taken a real step. The Ministry itself states that the Guideline may be further refined with data and feedback, and its May 2025 circular describes the Guideline as an interim measure that will form the basis for developing a new Bill to regulate digital health, including online health care services — a beginning, in other words, rather than a settlement.

What the next step must settle is what guidance cannot conclusively settle: what duties, if any, attach to the platform’s own role where it structures the encounter; and how standards are upheld proactively, rather than principally after a failure has surfaced.

That continuing development should build on the engagement already undertaken with health care professionals and professional associations, drawing on their experience of how the framework operates in practice.

Technology changes how medicine is delivered. It has never changed what medicine owes.

Dr Arasu R. is the Immediate Past President of the Malaysian Medical Association (MMA) and Chief Executive Officer of CareClinics Healthcare Services. He holds an MBA from Edinburgh Business School, Heriot-Watt University, and has completed the Leadership in Medicine programme at Harvard Medical School. His interests include primary care, health care leadership, digitalisation, and the future delivery of health care.

JJ Chan, an adjunct professor, is Managing Partner of CBE (Chan Ban Eng & Co), a Barrister-at-Law of the Honourable Society of Gray’s Inn, London, an Advocate & Solicitor of the High Court of Malaya, Alumni Ambassador (Malaysia) for City St George’s, University of London, Adjunct Professor at the Faculty of Law, Universiti Malaya and Founder of the Financial Lines Forum. He specialises in financial lines, medical negligence, corporate and directors’ liability, insurance/reinsurance, and AI governance risk. He also writes regularly on constitutional and public-interest matters.

  • This is the personal opinion of the writer or publication and does not necessarily represent the views of CodeBlue.

You may also like