Malaysia urgently needs more specialists, especially in Sabah, Sarawak, and hospitals far from major cities.
Yet, as doctors from the 2022 specialist-training intake approach their next placements, some of us have a painful question: will years spent serving the hardest-to-staff communities count for anything?
The imbalance is undeniable. As of March 31, 2026, Sabah had 221 vacant specialist positions out of 937 approved posts (23.6 per cent), while Sarawak had 177 vacancies out of 863 (20.5 per cent), according to parliamentary figures reported by CodeBlue.
In October, the Health Minister also disclosed that 382 of 1,055 medical officers offered permanent posts in these states this year did not report for duty.
Patients in remote communities pay the price for these shortages. We support equitable specialist distribution. What we question is whether that responsibility will once again fall disproportionately on doctors who had already answered the government’s call.
This is not a theoretical question for those of us awaiting pre-gazettement postings. Placement lists are being discussed now. Once expectations settle, correcting an inequitable process becomes immeasurably harder.
Two Pathways, Unequal Journeys
On August 30, 2022, the Ministry of Health (MOH) announced 1,347 offers for specialist training in the 2022/2023 academic session, covering medical, dental and parallel-pathway programmes.
Of these, 216 contract officers received offers under the newly introduced Program Latihan Kepakaran (PLK) dengan Biasiswa KKM. This reform, advanced during former Health Minister Khairy Jamaluddin’s tenure, finally opened a sponsored route to specialisation for contract doctors.
But the medical officers entering training did not all travel the same road.
Many permanent officers had accepted postings to Sabah, Sarawak or underserved district hospitals in pursuit of secure appointments, then served there for years before obtaining a Master’s training place. They crossed seas, lived away from family and worked where colleagues were scarce.
When the Covid-19 pandemic struck, some were mobilised into Covid-19 centres in smaller district hospitals and other health care facilities, facing the crisis with limited manpower and support.
They carried the burden of remote service before training even began. During the pandemic, there was little room to choose a comfortable assignment; patients needed care and we went where we were sent. Yet a bare list of preferred hospitals cannot capture that history.
The contract pathway brought a different experience for some. During 2021-2022, contract renewals allowed certain medical officers to remain in the very same hospital and department, sometimes in tertiary hospitals in the Klang Valley or other Peninsular cities. Some had remained at their preferred institutions since housemanship.
That continuity was permitted by the system; it does not diminish their work, nor does it describe every contract officer. Many contract doctors endured profound insecurity and hardship.
This is not a contest between permanent and contract doctors. It is a call to assess individual records fairly: where each officer served, for how long, and at what personal and professional cost.
A WhatsApp Message Is Not A Merit Assessment
Our immediate concern is the way placement preferences are being gathered in at least some specialties. Trainees have been asked, through WhatsApp messages and shared online spreadsheets editable by participants, simply to enter their preferred placement.
There is no field for years of previous service in Sabah, Sarawak, or underserved districts; no opportunity at this stage to document other merit-based considerations. Those of us who previously served where the service needed us are left wondering whether our histories are visible at all. When a shared sheet is editable by all participants, verification and an auditable record become even more important.
We recognise that a preference list may be only an early planning tool, not the final decision-making mechanism. But if a separate, comprehensive assessment will follow, why have affected trainees not been clearly informed? Who will verify the information, apply the criteria and resolve competing requests?
In 2025, MOH’s separate ePlacement system for permanent medical officers collected career information for weighted placement decisions. These are different cohorts, but surely doctors completing specialist training deserve an equally rigorous assessment and not uncertainty about whether any such assessment exists.
MOH’s own Surat Pekeliling Ketua Setiausaha Bilangan 1 Tahun 2023 requires merit-based placement and transfer decisions through designated committees. Its criteria refer to service needs, experience, and length of service; it also prohibits using outside influence to pressure decision-makers. These safeguards matter precisely when informal networks can leave some officers feeling unheard.
We are not alleging wrongdoing by any named officer or head of service. But a process that relies visibly on preferences alone, without explaining what happens next, invites distrust.
We fear that a poorly safeguarded process could become a loophole: those who have never served in remote areas may secure another preferred urban posting, while those who did are sent away again. Personal connections must never outweigh service.
Apply The Principle The Government Already Supports
On October 8, 2026, Health Minister Dzulkefly Ahmad announced a proposal for a 30 per cent specialist-training quota for medical officers serving in Sabah and Sarawak, together with additional merit for those who had served there when applying for training and study leave. We welcome that recognition.
But why should prior service count when applying to become a specialist, only to risk becoming invisible when that doctor is finally ready to serve as one?
Before placements are finalised, we ask MOH and the heads of service to disclose the assessment process; collect verified histories of postings; give meaningful, consistent weight to those who served in underserved facilities; and balance this against vacancies and training needs.
Everyone should receive the same opportunity to submit evidence and seek review. The criteria need not guarantee anyone a preferred hospital, but they must be transparent and applied equally.
Please Act Before The Lists Become Decisions
We understand that service needs must come first. We are prepared to serve Malaysians wherever necessary.
But fairness cannot mean repeatedly sending the same people to make sacrifices while past service by others is never considered. Responsibility for underserved communities must be shared, with reasonable accommodation for genuine hardship.
Minister of Health, Director-General of Health, heads of service, and those preparing these placements: please intervene now, while the lists can still be reviewed. A formal explanation of how merit will be assessed would restore confidence. Silence, until placement letters arrive, will deepen the feeling that loyalty has been taken for granted.
We crossed seas when called. We served through Covid-19 in places many would not choose. We kept faith with public health care because we believed service came first. We are not asking for wonders. We are asking for justice.
We have done our part. We would appreciate if you do yours, before it is too late.
CodeBlue is providing the author anonymity because civil servants are prohibited from writing to the press.
- This is the personal opinion of the writer or publication and does not necessarily represent the views of CodeBlue.

