PAC Questions MOH’s DRG Pricing Data Covering Only 39% Of Private Hospital Cases

The PAC questions whether private hospital billing data voluntarily submitted to MOH, covering just 39.4% of estimated cases, is representative enough to set DRG rates. MOH says MediAsas will initially use a hybrid payment arrangement.

KUALA LUMPUR, Nov 19 — The Ministry of Health (MOH) has collected data on billing by private hospitals that covers only 39.4 per cent of estimated inpatient admissions and day-care treatment.

Parliament’s Public Accounts Committee (PAC) questioned how the MOH could accurately determine the actual cost of private hospital treatment, in a bid to establish a diagnosis-related groups (DRG) reimbursement method, when a substantial proportion of cases remained outside its dataset.

PAC chairwoman Mas Ermieyati Samsudin also highlighted 56,512 cases for which billing data was unavailable.

“How can this dataset be sufficiently representative for us to use as the basis for developing DRG payment rates?” Mas Ermieyati, who is also Masjid Tanah MP, asked during an October 6 PAC proceeding with representatives from MOH, the Ministry of Finance (MOF), and Bank Negara Malaysia (BNM).

Hansard was published in the PAC’s 91-page report, tabled in the Dewan Rakyat last Tuesday, on follow-up action to its June 2026 report on rising medical insurance premiums, private hospital charges, and the impact on public health care.

According to the PAC’s new report, data on private hospital charges was collected through the Price, Admission, and Clinical Electronic Datahub (PACED), a system developed by ProtectHealth Corporation, a company fully owned by the MOH, to support the government’s DRG initiative.

It’s unclear whether the data was hospital bills to insurers or charges to uninsured patients paying out of pocket. 

MOH Health Transformation Office chief executive Dr Yap Wei Aun said participation in the data collection exercise was voluntary, and that the 39.4 per cent coverage exceeded the ministry’s initial expectations.

“The 39 per cent figure is much higher than our expectations when we first started implementing this project,” Dr Yap told the committee.

The dataset represented nearly RM5 billion in private health care financing, Dr Yap said, but acknowledged that MOH needed to analyse the information rather than simply rely on figures submitted by hospitals.

“What is important is that we should not simply trust the data alone. We have to carry out the appropriate analysis. This is currently being undertaken,” he said.

MOH is examining the range and distribution of prices within individual DRG groupings to determine appropriate payment rates, he added.

DRGs group patients with similar diagnoses and treatment requirements into categories with standardised payments. The system is intended to shift private health care financing away from the fee-for-service model, under which hospitals bill separately for consultations, procedures, medicines, and other components of treatment.

However, implementing DRG payments will require improvements in private hospitals’ clinical coding and data collection systems, Dr Yap said.

“If we had a complete system, with perfect coding by private hospitals and perfect data, that would mean we would not need to implement DRG in phases. We could simply switch it on and off. By January, it would be fully ready,” he said.

“However, because we understand that we are accelerating a highly complex process, we need to adopt a phased approach.”

MOH will initially use a hybrid payment arrangement for MediAsas, a proposed government-designed base medical and health insurance/takaful (MHIT) product, rather than rely entirely on DRG-based rates. Private hospitals currently use a fee-for-service model.

The phased rollout is intended to give private hospitals time to improve their coding and data collection before DRG payments are expanded under MediAsas that is fully underwritten by insurance and takaful operators (ITOs). 

MediAsas is scheduled for public launch in January 2027, with DRG-based financing to be introduced progressively.

Dr Yap said MediAsas could also provide the government with a means of controlling private hospital charges before amendments to the Private Healthcare Facilities and Services Act 1998 (Act 586) are enacted.

“Even without implementing any amendments, what is important is that we can use this MediAsas platform to control hospital charges. Not only consultation fees, but all other hospital charges as well,” he told the PAC.

The proposed amendments would expand MOH’s regulatory authority beyond doctors’ professional fees to cover other components of private hospital bills. The ministry intends to use data from MediAsas and the national DRG exercise as an empirical basis for determining the scope of those powers.

MOH Deputy Sec-Gen Warns Of ‘Unintended Consequences’ From Arbitrary Price Regulation

Ministry of Health deputy secretary-general (finance and development) Zahrul Hakim Abdullah speaks in a Public Accounts Committee proceeding in Parliament on October 6, 2026. Photo by Adnan Khalip/Parlimen Malaysia.

But MOH deputy secretary-general (finance and development) Zahrul Hakim Abdullah cautioned against expanding price regulation without first understanding hospitals’ underlying cost structures.

“Regulating prices alone without understanding the cost structure could produce unintended consequences,” Zahrul told the PAC.

Zahrul said private hospital bills included charges beyond doctors’ professional fees, and that the government needed to understand the underlying costs and how they were determined before deciding how to regulate them.

The timing of amendments to Act 586 would depend on the implementation of MediAsas and the national DRG system, which is expected to be fully completed by the first quarter of 2028, Zahrul said.

The timeline drew concern from the PAC, which had previously recommended expediting DRG implementation in the private sector to encourage greater cost efficiency. The committee also called for amendments to Act 586 to give MOH wider powers to regulate private hospital charges.

“The PAC expresses concern over the postponement of amendments to the Private Healthcare Facilities and Services Act 1998 (Act 586) until the first quarter of 2028. This prolonged transition period risks continuing to expose consumers to charge manipulation and excessive profit margins imposed on non-professional components of private hospital services.”

As the 15th Parliament is due for automatic dissolution in December 2027, it’s up to the government elected in the 16th general election to introduce proposed Act 586 amendments if the Madani administration doesn’t table the amendment bill next year.

The PAC said the phased implementation of DRG through MediAsas should also be monitored to provide empirical evidence for determining the scope of amendments to Act 586, subject to assessments of feasibility and MOH’s regulatory capacity.

You may also like